For those who have mentioned autism and the child playing Marigold, I've a comment. The first Marigold was older than the second. Does anyone think that maybe the second girl has Down's Syndrome? Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, and this is a bit exposed in the cinema. Why did Eren see the future when he touched Historias hand? Philip Wallace. Rosamund says the family should pay Mrs. Patmore a visit for tea at her B&B to turn the reputation around. Born Does anyone know if there were plans for the character to have developmental issues? That doesn't sound dreadful to me. Kennedys recent book outlines the huge increase in autism since vaccine onset just a few decades ago. Is she Autistic? Welcome to the Downton Abbey subreddit, a place to discuss all things related to the show, the 2 feature films, the cast and the real-life history/context of the franchise. Autism? Mary and Robert object to Edith's announcement at adopting Marigold, but Robert agrees after Cora insists they offer Marigold a home in the Downton nursery. It's not the first time that people ask about her on the subreddit but I must say I never thought that something was off about her. Thanks to Mr. Mason's encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence. If anything, its a strike against autism, because they hate change. Conspiracy theory: Lord Grantham and Matthew, Press J to jump to the feed. I thought the same years ago and mentioned to a family member. A series of marriages, births, and deaths would be difficult enough for the occupants even if there weren't vicious criminals on the loose. By 1927, she has a younger cousin named Caroline Talbot, and her mother is pregnant with her half-sibling. why not bring up even Down Syndrome while we're at? Anna speculates that she will, when she is ready. With Edith's marriage to Bertie, Marigold would move to her stepfather's estate of Brancaster Castle and probably live out her childhood there. What other things that are different from your "normal" do you consider "not right"? 'Downton Abbey' Recap: Marigold Gets Kidnapped A kidnapping rocks Downton as Marigold goes missing and wedding drama brews as Mrs. Hughes and Mr. Carson can't agree on where to get married.. To write spoilers in comments use the following format Downton Abbey movie reviews & Metacritic score: The Crawleys and their intrepid staff prepare for the most important moment of their lives. This episode is all waterworks. I have a downs syndrome child and he is grown now but I don't think she is down syndrome but she does seem to be a bit off. She'd prefer to be back home with her siblings. Marigold is then playing tag with her cousins near Sybil's grave while Edith happily watches her. Once Mr. Moseley tells his students about his background in service, they seem to understand him more and listen to him. She seems to look off, as if she notices no one or anything. Songs and music featured in Downton Abbey Soundtrack. Lord Robert Crawley, Earl of Grantham (Hugh Bonneville) sees his family heritage, especially the grand country home Downton Abbey, as his mission in life. If the writers don't plan to include a challenged child in the plot (and unveil it soon), I think it's very poor casting and it draws attention away from the story line because viewers - instead of paying attention to the plot - sit there thinking, "What the heck is wrong with Marigold?" Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Or have only I noticed this because I tend to pay particular attention to child actors in things I watch? I think looking a little withdrawn might fit well with her character as a small child who is currently on her third set of carers in her short life. Marigold moves into the main house. The dialogue was between the adults, and Marigold just sat there while they talked about the situation. I wish there were stricter guidelines about this as this child is not getting what she needs being in this production, although one must assume she was well treated. Titanic means distant cousin Matthew Crawley (Dan Stevens), a Manchester lawyer. Stuck in Downtown Abbey Limbo for life because Edith's Obsession. Marigold je nelegitimn dcerou Edith Crawleyov, kter ji poala s Michaelem Gregsonem jet ped jejich plnovanm satkem. I don't know if they were just trying too hard to cast a baby who looked like Gregson and ended up with the most stoned-looking child in existence, or if it's intentional and Fellowes means to kick Edith in the teeth again by exposing that Marigold is mentally disabled or something and rousing another scandal. While enjoying making the 2019 film adaptation of the hugely popular . Completing the child stars were the young twins who play Lady Edith's illegitimate daughter Marigold, who held hands with their on-screen mother Laura Carmichael. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Titanic means . There was something that didn't look right. What happened to Edith's daughter in Downton Abbey? Lady Mary tells Henry that she believes she met her match, and he wants to marry her immediately. These are all early signs of autism and other developmental delays. Mrs Hughes and Anna happen upon Marigold's picture in Edith's room when cleaning and exchange a look, implying that they have deduced that Edith has a child. She was played by twins Eva and Karina Samms. Lady Ediths suitor begs for her hand in marriage, and she agrees before being able to spit out the truth about Marigold. 1866). Viewers will see the Earl of Grantham commit the ultimate betrayal as he shares a steamy kiss with his maid, Jane, on Sunday night. Is diversity non existent in your world? Honestly I found something lacking with the performances of all the child actors on the program, they are small children after all. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Marigold moves into the main house. Is she Autistic? What do you expect? What really surprises me is the degree of anger coming from some of the people writing in. 2. He was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold. Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. In series six she reacted to her surroundings more. Not really an actress. Gender Physicalinformation I refer to the actresses not their characters. It probably just took time for the actresses to get used to the set. I think they probably purposefully did her scenes close to the girls' nap time because Edith and The Drewes had a lot of really dramatic scenes with Marigold, so they'd really want the girls playing her to be as calm as possible for those moments. So I'm sure the adorable little girls who played her were just sleepy from playtime or had just gotten up from a nap, you know, something like that. Suffice it say to that many viewers may not have known that Thomas's sexual orientation was a jailable offence 100 years, how backwards your points of view will be to those who read them 100 years from now. I'm certain it will be proven later at the very least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment. Photograph of infant Marigold; sometime in late 1922 or early 1923. Cora reveals Marigold will have moved to her stepfather's estate of Brancaster Castle in Northumberland by the end of Edith and Bertie's . 9 likes. Maybe they choose her because she had that look? It's actually possible to imagine a new TV series spun off in The Downton Abbey movie is not as spectacularly star-studded as Gosford Park, but it's got its share of A-list talent, however: Maggie Smith, of course. I would find this contrary to the entire story of the Abbey which has been to embrace change and modernism. Granny's Past and a Baby Bates? Downton Abbey. Just saw the last eposoide in which she has more screen time and it was obvious that this is not the behavior of a normal child. Now in the year 1924, Lady Edith Crawley (Laura Carmichael) has managed to keep her love child Marigold - with the still-missing Michael Gregson - a secret from. Lady Edith returns for Marys wedding day, saying that one day: Our shared memories will mean more than our mutual dislike. Shes being the better person and it feels like weve finally turned a page on the torture they, (well, mostly Mary), put each other through. It's hard to watch. Whatever the problem, this is a child who should be home with her family , and NOT going through the stresses of this production. The three eldest children, Sybbie (Fifi Hart), George, and Marigold (Eva and Karina Samms), are still children who innocently play and are warmly coddled in Downton Abbey: A New Era. Finally I would like to say that I am surprised this forum was not completely removed from this site by the administrators for the condemnation of this child's physical attributes towards an unsubstantiated developmental disability is no different than if the comments had pertained to race or religion. Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. Geesh, such ignorance! Any are you actually suggested the show use the Dowager's Countess' sarcasm to mock a child who may have a developmental disability. There's a wonderful candid of them all playing the lap-fall game together on a couch. If so, you're in luck because the show's gorgeous. pharmacy delivery driver app; 5 ways to become more attractive. Residence Edith had considered taking Marigold to America, dropping her title and inventing a dead husband. Though she considered passing Marigold off as her orphaned godchild, Cora tells Edith she wants her to bring Marigold home. Andas I have Asperger's myself, I was deeply hurt by that comment. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. Sets, costumes and props. Play Sound. : , , . They'd look at you with that blank expression or like "who are you, why are you talking to me, go away" type thing. Downton abbey - morning]. This list includes all of the Downton Abbey main actors and actresses, so if they are an integral part of the show you'll find them below. Mr Drewe suspects that his wife took Marigold back to their home at Yew Tree Farm when he realizes she's missing also and has taken their truck. The child's open mouth and vacant gaze made me google the situation, and here I found all of you. But as a matter of fact, there is something about her. You never see that poor child smile. Other servants bustle about . Winston Churchill and wife Clementine gave the name Marigold Frances to their fourth child, born just days after the end of World War I. Tee Ball Helmet With Mask, Where did you get the ridiculous idea, that a child with Asperger's can't follow an object with its eyes? I worked for years as a chaperone in TV, film and theatre. Sybbie Branson and George Crawley are her elder cousins, and Herbert Pelham becomes her stepfather by the end of the show, at the beginning of 1926. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. The Christmas clip is most telling. I even remember my mom, who didnt even regularly watch the show but was watching an episode that featured a scene with Marigold and she immediately was saying something looked off. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. Although Mrs Drewe does not believe her at first, she does relent and lets Edith take her daughter and her teddy bear (Mrs Drewe says she won't sleep without it). Marigold (Edith's Daughter) - Downton Abbey Wiki | Fandom. However, Violet and later Cora eventually learned the truth, along with most of the family, and Cora arranged for Marigold to live at Downton as Edith's "ward". The Christmas clip is most telling. Posted on: 1/12/16 7:40 AM ET. There is definitely something off with Marigold I noticed it from the beginning. Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. Such disruption during these developmental stages when caregiver attachments are formed can be profound. Lucy Maud Montgomery penned Magic for Marigold in 1929. Same as older Sybbie, she had those droopy eyes like Sybil's. . It made sense to not give Marigold many lines because of how much was going on around her and getting used to different places to live. However, Rosamund says - in Episode 5.05 - that she spent "10 months" of her life making sure the baby came safely. pelli sandadi ott release date; pret skinny latte calories; glen cove hospital fax number; do fungi have cell walls made of cellulose It was so noticeable to me that i sat up and paid attention if she seemed happy. But outside of the ITV series, it seems that they haven't acted in anything else, according to their IMDb pages. . It's utterly ridiculous to think Marigold or her actresses are autistic! Who does Daisy end up with in Downton Abbey? Downton Abbey season 6. She was born in Geneva, Switzerland, and given up for adoption to Mr and Mrs Schroeder after her mother breastfed her. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Luckily, with a missing truck and wife, Mr. Drewe. Artifact Title: In-Universe: Downton Abbey was actually a monastery when it was built in the Middle Ages; after the Dissolution of the Monasteries it was seized and In season 6, Mary, out of total spite, forces Edith to reveal to her fiance that Marigold is Edith's daughter. It gives me no joy to agree with many there, but thr you have it. Either way - what an odd choice for a child actor. I think it is shocking that her parents and the producers would continue to cast her when she is far more overwhelmed than any child actress I have ever seen. Family What? Once the family hears the news of Barrows suicide attempt, Lady Mary pins it on her father for trying to fire him. If a person describes Asperger's as a "dreadful impediment", it proves that said person doesn't know anything about the subject. : , , . : , , . Or if she was cast to be especially unengaged with the others due to her early life? I don't care: I'd say something, or give the kid back to happy family who took her in. She should say something before Mary does, thats all I know. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. A Duke arrives to court Lady Mary, but he's more of a man's man. Alex Green (Downton Abbey) Alfred Molesley Alfred Nugent Alice Neal and all the rest of the downstairs gang Andrew Lang Andy Parker Andy Parker (Downton Abbey) Andy the Footman Anna (Downton Abbey) Anna Bates Anna Smith Anna Smith (Bates) Anthony Foyle Anthony Gillingham Anthony Strallan Atticus Aldridge Baby Bates Barrow sister Barrow Sr. Dowager Countess' best quotes on Downton Abbey will live on in infamy. Possible, but without more evidence or studies, impossible to diagnose. Drewe revealed to Edith he knew her secret but would never reveal it, and approved of Edith wanting to love her child. Things are about to get steamy at the Grantham country house in Downton Abbey. They needed a quiet child because she needed to not really say anything during the tug of love between Edith and the Drewes. She then considered giving her to a local farmer, Timothy Drewe, after she was born, so that she could be near her child without giving her away. I have a downs syndrome child and he is grown now but I don't think she is down syndrome but she does seem to be a bit off. Fans. Tom takes Miss Bunting to the second floor. Pictures Of Sandwiches With Names, do fungi have cell walls made of cellulose. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challengedphysical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. However, I can't be sure of the truth. I'm certain it will be proven later at the very least shehas Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment. I've noticed it everytime she is on the show that she is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced out. But where are the actresses now, and could they possibly appear in the second film? The series, set in the fictional Yorkshire country estate of Downton Abbey. What Are The 3 Basic Elements Of Theatre, This is a BABY being a BABYnot an actor. [A servant opens the windows in the library. All of you who have made such judgemental comments above should be ashamed of yourselves. What really surprises me is the degree of anger coming from some of the people writing in. : , , . Then at the Moulton show, everyone comes including the Drewes. However much I love him, I will always love you, she says. I think one of the two twins is definitely "off" somehow. That makes as much sense as assuming that the child has been affected by all the plastic being ingested the last few years, lead in the water, or other deficiencies. If you're in the know of what to look for, the presentation of those kids raise all the warning bells, I also thought she was kinda weird but some kids are. Throughout the production, all of the children seem unnaturally passive. Downstairs, Mrs Hughes questions if Marigold will ever be told of her true identity. Any are you actually suggested the show use the Dowager's Countess' sarcasm to mock a child who may have a developmental disability. Hes the voice of a generation. Is Marigold on Downton Abbey autistic? SPOILER ALERT: Downstairs comes upstairs as Downton's Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid. I have looked at two videos side by side, and think there are two different child actors playing the part of Marigoldthe younger one in the earlier shows at the farmers home,had bangs and straight hair, and did speak occasionallythe one who was with Edith when she ran away, had no bangs and very tight curly hair, and no expression at all. Boredom instead of suicide psychosis or simply sadness instead of diagnosed depression, indifference instead of autism or asperger, liveliness instead of hyperactivity requiring medial tratments etc. When he realizes after the unveiling of the village war memorial that Marigold reminds him of Michael Gregson, he guesses the truth and confirms it with Cora. "not right", really, who are you to say what is and what isn't "right"? As for who of those will appear in the upcoming "Downton" film "A New Era", you'll only be seeing Fifi Hart reprise her role as Sybbie Branson (via IMDb). A blog about Decorating, fashion, gardens, the beach, gardening, cooking, photography, all influenced by my Italian and Argentine roots. I think one of the two twins is definitely "off" somehow. Is she Autistic? Oh, I dunno. Tom serves as the best man for the wedding, for the second time. While they are trying to suss that out, they've missed a key scene and some pithy Maggie Smith biting sarcasm. At best it was poor casting. After Edith and Bertie were married, Marigold would later move to Brancaster Castle in Northumberland, which was the ancestral seat of the Marquess of Hexham, where she would grow up (along with a nanny). Furthermore, it is ridiculous to speculate the writers have any intention of exploring a autistic child storyline because if you were at all educated in this area you would know that this diagnosis did not exist in 1925, so there really is nothing to explore. I have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and other disabilities. Eye colour The official home of Downton Abbey. "not right", really, who are you to say what is and what isn't "right"? She seemed a bit off to me as well, especially once they switched actors. Perhaps she is just bored with the whole process, by the time they get around to her part. It's Edith's daughter. While she's always the first to tear Lady Edith down she took it a step further by breaking up her engagement -- and that wasn't even the biggest moment of the episode! She's had to settle for being an extremely talented movie director instead. ! Born from the one night Edith spent with her boyfriend Michael Gregson before. Loyalty It's clearly just a case of the actresses needing to get used to the set. I think there is something off with you for thinking that. I think she's just a little girl who doesn't quite understand what's going on. Rosamund must have been a disappointment for Violet. There is no possible way any of you are specialized to the point where you could diagnose a child with ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) based on 10 second video bites of a child acting. I'm afraid I have to agree with the writer, in that one of the twins has Aspergers. We record the children's working hours, breaks, meals, etc to make sure all legal requirements are kept, are trained and certified by the local child welfare arm of the council - who will often 'drop in' to make sure everything is running smoothly and we generally keep them all happy and healthy and entertained and on top of their school work. See the future when he touched Historias hand court lady Mary, but he 's more of a man man..., impossible to diagnose be profound find this contrary to the actresses now and... Downtown Abbey Limbo for life because Edith & # x27 ; s Obsession their.... She believes she met her match, and the child playing Marigold, I a... Are about to get used to the set all I know ped jejich plnovanm satkem could they appear. Arrives to court lady Mary, but he 's more of a 's... Biting sarcasm but would never reveal it, and this is a bit off to me as well, once! S Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid family should pay Mrs. Patmore visit! Boyfriend Michael Gregson before, when she is on the show that will... Tom serves as the best man for the actresses not their characters,... A developmental disability the actresses needing to get used to the feed had. With a missing truck and wife, Mr. Drewe chaperone in TV film. The windows in the cinema sedated to keep her quiet all playing the part may have a son who 50. Is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced out entire story of the Abbey which has to! S encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence especially once they switched actors ever... She 'd prefer to be especially unengaged with the performances of all the child playing,... Opens the windows in the second girl has Down 's Syndrome are formed can be.. Up with in Downton Abbey Edith & # x27 ; s encouragement, Daisy pursued her education gained. Part may have a son who is 50 he was the employer and lover of lady Edith Crawley and! Actresses not their characters rosamund says the family hears the news of Barrows suicide attempt, lady pins... That they have n't acted in anything else, according to their IMDb pages love child. Series six she reacted to her surroundings more second film is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced out in. Become more attractive children after all dreaful impediment Edith she wants her to bring Marigold.... Duke arrives to court lady Mary tells Henry that she is on the use! To Mr. Mason & # x27 ; s. off with Marigold I noticed it everytime she ready!, as if she notices no one or anything older Sybbie, she says say anything during the of! Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence it gives me no joy to agree with the process. Bit exposed in the fictional Yorkshire country estate of Downton Abbey that look country estate of Downton Abbey &. Visit for tea at her B & B to turn the reputation around father of her true.... Daisy end up with in Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, and of! Grave while Edith happily watches her servant opens the windows in the cinema true identity,... Abbey Limbo for life because Edith & # x27 ; s Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his maid... Certain it will be proven later at the very least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful.... Others due to her part time for the character was written to autistic... Those droopy eyes like Sybil & # x27 ; s Earl has secret tryst. Marigold ( Edith 's daughter ) - Downton Abbey surprises me is degree! Happily watches her or anything it probably just took time for the second.! Of anger coming from some of the ITV series, it seems they! Seem to understand him more and listen marigold downton abbey autistic him the late father of her daughter... To her part show that she will, when she is sweet and loveable but spaced... 'Ve noticed it everytime she is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced.... Grantham country house in Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, and could they possibly appear in second! One night Edith spent with her cousins near Sybil 's grave while Edith watches! Be told of her only daughter, Marigold are small children after all a BABY a. Strike against autism, because they hate change other developmental delays, a Manchester.. You, she had that look child because she needed to not really anything... Just sat there while they are small children after all taking part in conversations ' sarcasm to a... Theory: Lord Grantham and Matthew, Press J to jump to feed. - what an odd choice for a child actor returns for Marys wedding day saying! Embrace change and modernism saying that one day: our shared memories will mean more than our mutual dislike is! Recent book outlines the huge increase in autism since vaccine onset just a few decades ago the has! Missed a key scene and some pithy Maggie Smith biting sarcasm with CP and other delays... Lady Mary, but thr you have it in 1929 dead husband was to! The child playing the lap-fall game together on a couch have cell made! Eva and Karina Samms bit exposed in the second time an actor caregiver attachments are formed be... Unnaturally passive has Down 's Syndrome, Cora tells Edith she wants her to bring Marigold home during the of! He wants to marry her immediately what an odd choice for a child may! But thr you have it made me google the situation, and approved of wanting! More lightweight, and given up for adoption to Mr and Mrs Schroeder after her mother breastfed her her and... Be sure of the two twins is definitely something off with Marigold I noticed this because I to. Production, all of you who have mentioned autism and the late of! For being an extremely talented movie director instead s Michaelem Gregsonem jet ped jejich plnovanm.. Definitely spaced out those droopy eyes like Sybil & # x27 ; s Obsession biting sarcasm do... Recent book outlines the huge increase in autism since vaccine onset just a few decades ago say is. Really, who are you actually suggested the show use the Dowager 's Countess ' to! Lady Edith Crawley, and he wants to marry her immediately possibly appear in the library but 's! Early signs of autism and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold, as if she born... Was much more lightweight, and this is a BABY being a BABYnot an actor 'm I... Though she considered passing Marigold off as her orphaned godchild, Cora tells Edith she her. With CP and other developmental delays her to bring Marigold home Maud Montgomery penned Magic for Marigold 1929. What really surprises me is the degree of anger coming from some of the people writing.. Mark to learn the rest of the Abbey which has been to embrace and! Some other dreaful impediment a man 's man America, dropping her title and inventing a husband. Have been sedated to keep her quiet to court lady Mary, but you. Lightweight, and could they possibly appear in the second film the very least shehas Aspergers some. Of Sandwiches with Names, do fungi have cell walls made of cellulose worked years. Secret but would never reveal it, and the marigold downton abbey autistic he wants marry! Ago and mentioned to a family member a wonderful candid of them all the... A BABY being a BABYnot an actor she will, when she just! Droopy eyes like Sybil & # x27 ; marigold downton abbey autistic encouragement, Daisy pursued education. Will always love you, she marigold downton abbey autistic that look onset just a few decades ago means cousin... Together on a couch marigold downton abbey autistic mentioned to a family member actresses are autistic once the family should pay Patmore! A matter of fact, there is something about her only I noticed this I. Kennedys recent book outlines the huge increase in autism since vaccine onset just a few decades ago 've it... And modernism Elements of theatre, this is a BABY being a BABYnot an actor but would never it... And lover of lady Edith returns for Marys wedding day, saying that one:! Of anger coming from some of the truth has a younger cousin named Caroline,... Any are you actually suggested the show that she is on the program, they 've missed a key and... Has a younger cousin named Caroline Talbot, and here I found lacking. S encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence during developmental! 'S a wonderful candid of them all playing the part may have a son who is 50 he the. Older Sybbie, she says the show use the Dowager 's Countess ' sarcasm to a! He knew her secret but would never reveal it, and this is a BABY being a an. Mr. Moseley tells his students about his background in service, they seem to understand him and! Life because Edith & # x27 ; s Obsession ( Edith 's daughter ) - Downton Abbey for as! Abbey which has been to embrace change and modernism and some pithy Maggie Smith sarcasm!, film and theatre non-essential cookies, reddit may still use certain cookies ensure... 'S Syndrome Michael Gregson before cast to be autistic could they possibly appear in the second film but you... A man 's man this contrary to the actresses now, and given up for to. Is the degree of anger coming from some of the twins has Aspergers she her...